Buried in books . . .
Okay, buried in online white papers is a little closer to the truth. I’ve been reading white papers on contract law, agency law, and ethical dilemmas in decision making for a class that I’m taking (MBA). I think my eyes are starting to cross . . .
Anyhow, an ethical dilemmas paper reminded me of the reasoning behind the creation of my blog. I understand the fears behind the threat of malpractice suits, but I think these questions suggested in the white paper can be used by decision makers in any profession:
“First, do the gut test: Is my gut telling me I can live with this answer? Do I believe it is the right thing to do and that it best serves everyone’s interests?
Second, do the transparency test: Would it be okay if the decision and the rationale behind it were published on the front page of the Wall Street Journal [or a medical journal . . .or an online blog]?
Third, do the legacy test: Would you be proud to share this decision and the rationale behind it with your grandchildren?
If the answers to all of the above are yes, then go with the decision. If not, re-examine it.”
(The paper referenced J.L. Badaracco, Defining moments: when managers must choose between right and right.; R. Bolt, A man for all seasons.; T. Lickona,Moral development and behavior: theory, research, and social issues.)
I would add, “Would I want someone to make this same decision regarding one of my family members or friends?”
Sometimes the decisions that keep us secure and make us feel safe are still the wrong decisions—they aren’t ethical. Please take the time necessary to evaluate your decisions carefully before they are “set in stone.”
